The Kidd Vs. Remember Me
“Remember Me” is a mediocre to average film from start to a few moments before the end. Then it dives right into what might be one of the most unnecessary, insulting, and ridiculous endings that will have you watching the remaining few minutes shaking your head in shame and disgust that you spent two hours of your life sitting in a theatre, waiting to see where this was going, curious to see how they would resolve the issues of the movie only for them to arrive at THAT.
If you have any intentions of ever seeing “Remember Me,” you might want to stop reading right now until you get a chance to take in the film. Because this review is going to be spoiler-heavy. It has to be. It would actually be irresponsible of me not to discuss specific details of “Remember Me,” particularly the ending, because that’s what the whole movie rests on. So, if you were planning on going in fresh, you might want to think twice about proceeding. You have been warned.
“Remember Me” is almost set up as a more serious version of “She’s All That,” except substitute an always smoking, always brooding Robert Pattinson for an always goofy Freddie Prinze Jr. Now, of course minus the humor of “She’s All That,” there are many more layers to the characters involved here, but the basic premise of the movie is about a guy who decides to start dating a girl for ulterior motives, falls in love with the girl during the process, reveals the truth to the girl, and then the aftermath. Sure, we’ve seen this plot play out over many different films and TV shows (“10 Things I Hate About You” also comes to mind recently), but, for the sake of argument, The Kidd is going to stick with “She’s All That” to make my point.
So, now try to recall “She’s All That” with a little help from The Kidd. Freddie Prinze Jr. gets talked into dating Rachael Leigh Cook at the prompting of his asshole best friend for all the wrong reasons. Through the charade, Prinze begins to develop feelings for his female counterpart, she feels likewise, they fall in love. Eventually, it gets to the point where the basis of their relationship can’t stay a secret any longer, and Cook finds out that Prinze wasn’t into her from the start. He only asked her out, because he’s an asshole, but he explains how he got to know her through their time spent together and how he grew to care for that girl. He was able to reveal all of his secrets to someone he trusted. She was able to do the same… but it’s too late. She now hates him for hurting her. He hates himself for being a dick. Because we can’t have this end with the two of them split like this, eventually they get back together. She forgives him for what he did, because, regardless of the past, their current emotions are real, and they are able to resume their relationship as it stood before the truth got in the way and messed things up. Everything seems to be resolved and ready to send us off knowing that this couple will live happily ever after, and then Freddie Prinze Jr. goes out one morning and… BAM…!!!
HE DIES IN THE WORLD TRADE CENTER ON 9/11!!!
What…? W…T…F…?! Really…?! Seriously…?! WHAT… THE… FUCK…?!
Yep. That’s right. Just when everything was nicely wrapped up, they decided to kill the protagonist using the most heinous terrorist attack to ever take place on American soil as a plot device. Classy… really classy.
And right when you are able to wrap your head around what is about to happen, you find yourself saying to yourself “please tell me they’re not going where i think they’re going.” But it’s no use. They’re going there… and it is awful.
I was able to do the math of the major events that take place throughout the film – the date of a murder, the time of a suicide – and, while I had my fingers crossed that they weren’t planning on bringing September 11th into this for no reason whatsoever, I should have known better. And it isn’t just the use of the date we’re stuck with either. Oh, no… you get a full pullback of Robert Pattinson looking out the window of a high floor in one of the towers. Yep, a digitally recreated version of the World Trade Center makes an appearance also. Luckily, we’re spared having to see a special effects-driven look at the planes hitting the buildings, but I’m not entirely sure why. Granted, I never have to see those images again for as long as I live, what with them being permanently etched in my memory forever. But why stop where they did? I mean, you’re already using denigrating September 11th by using it to drive the end of your movie… why not just go all the way? Well, that’s simple… because there was never any thought given to the responsibility that comes with invoking 9/11 for anything. It was almost as if they decided to end the movie with September 11th, and then wrote everything backwards, since there is absolutely nothing that takes place throughout the movie that would lead you to think Pattinson’s dying would take place when and where it does. And that’s what is so infuriating about where “Remember Me” goes. 9/11 is used to get you talking about this movie, to get you debating and arguing about why it’s included, to get you to actually remember “Remember Me.” Well, don’t worry, Summit Entertainment, director Allen Coulter, or writer Will Fetters… there is no way I will ever forget what I saw in “Remember Me.” In fact, this movie might go down in my history books as having the single worst movie ending I have ever seen. Congratulations. It really takes something to claim that position, but you were all able to do it with ease. Wow.
I won’t use the argument that it’s too soon, because I don’t know that there will ever be a time when using 9/11 in a movie will be okay. Granted, there have been two films released since 2001 that have centered around that fateful day, Paul Greengrass’ “United 93” and Oliver Stone’s “World Trade Center,” but those are two movies based around the events of September 11th. They try to tell stories of heroism of those involved in what happened that day, and you can argue that they are movies you wouldn’t want to see because of their subject matter, and I understand your perspective. But, in defense of them, they didn’t just throw 9/11 out there as a way of killing off a character, who could have easily been hit by a car or been stabbed in a mugging or any much more logical deaths. Something along those lines would have had the same emotional impact they were attempting to yank from me, but without taking me out of the movie to think to myself “I can’t believe they just fuckin’ did that.”
“Remember Me” follows Robert Pattinson as Tyler, a young guy who seems to have given up on life, a guy who doesn’t give a shit anymore. Sure, Tyler could have made something out of his life, since he’s presented as being smart and charming, with every opportunity available to him that he ever wanted with the financial resources his father, played by Pierce Brosnan, could aid him with. But, he found his brother dead at the age of 22, having killed himself… and from then on, he hasn’t been the same. He’s grown closer to his family – his little sister, his mom, his stepfather, as a result… but his dad didn’t handle it very well at all, and pushed himself into his work, as a partner of a big time law firm and away from his family. There you have all the basis for a strained relationship between Tyler and Mr. Charles Hawkins, and, being a more complex role than Edward Cullen, Pattinson has a lot more to do here. Instead of just staring at his love interest, he gets to laugh and yell some, too. He gets to show a bit more personality than the mysteriously angsty vampire will allow. He gets to show a little bit of his acting skill here, and he’s not that bad. He’s still not all that charismatic to me. He still comes across as rather drab and boring. And, frankly, when all the girls swoon over his giant wall of hair and his quiet demeanor, I just don’t get it. Needless to say, Pattinson fans will love whatever he does, whatever he says, whatever he’s in. And the anti-Pattinson fans don’t want to see anything he’s in anyway. So that leaves those of us in the middle to pass judgment, and I don’t think there’s anything about Tyler to really hook you on the love story of “Remember Me,” because it is entirely dependent upon the relationship between him and Ally (Claire from “Lost”), and that’s not a good thing.
Ally has her own issues, having watched her mother gunned down on a subway platform, after already giving up all of her valuables in a robbery. She’s left to be raised in a single-parent household, which wouldn’t be a problem if her dad wasn’t a cop, Sgt. Neil Craig, played by Chris Cooper. He makes up for the fact that he lost his wife by smothering his daughter, carefully keeping an eye on every move she makes, everything she does. Clearly the products of two strained parent-child relationships that both suffered traumatic losses can only lead to something good (insert eyeroll here).
After a night of drinking with his annoying idiot friend Aidan, played to convincing irritation levels by Tate Ellington, Tyler and his bud get arrested for trying to stop a random act of violence with their own random act of violence. Yet, after being cleared as merely trying to break things up, Tyler feels the need to antagonize the arresting officer for taking in the wrong guys. Who’s the arresting officer? That was too easy. Of course, coincidentally it was Sgt. Craig, who coincidentally has a daughter that goes to the same school as Tyler and Aidan. Aidan coincidentally sees her get dropped off by her dad one morning, and then the plan is hatched for Tyler to put his smooth moves on the daughter of the cop with what in mind exactly? Who knows? Was it meant to hurt her, which would hurt her dad in a roundabout way? Was it to piss off the cop with the knowledge that his daughter is dating a criminal? Does it matter? The plan goes into effect, and we’re off and running with this stupid movie towards the worst finish line ever.
I wish I could say even the middle of the movie was tolerable, but it is average on a generous day, because there is no reason to care about this relationship between these two people period. There is zero chemistry between them, to the point that you’re surprised that there was ever a second date, because their first date that we get to witness was boring as hell. You know… the more I think about it, the more the ending pisses me off. “Remember Me” has reduced 9/11 to a cheap plot device to get you upset about Robert Pattinson dying, but it’s not him we give a shit about. It’s remembering where we were on that day, what we saw, and what we will never be able to forget.
I grew up in New Jersey, right in the shadow of New York City, and, for the first 18 years of my life, I was able to see the New York skyline every single day, which included the World Trade Center. It was a part of my everyday life, so there was deep emotional impact on September 11, 2001, when those events unfolded. Even going back to visit family and friends, it isn’t the same to look out at the city because of that glaring omission. I had been to Ground Zero in December of 2001. I saw the twisted metal. I saw the dust still on the streets. I know people who were lucky enough somehow to not be in one of those buildings on that day. I know people that weren’t so lucky. I know friends who have lost loved ones, family members, dear friends on that tragic day. So, for all of that to be used as just a way to kill Robert Pattinson is disgraceful. I’m not bothered that Pattinson died. I’m bothered that you used 9/11 to do it, you assholes.
I’d like to send thank-you’s to both director Allen Coulter and writer Will Fetters for making “Remember Me.” My worst movies of all-time list was getting rather stale, and yet they managed to create a motion picture that now sits firmly atop those rankings, bumping the crown off “Napoleon Dynamite” after all these years. And, to find a movie that can bring about such outrage in me by merely mentioning its name is a special feat. But, good job, “Remember Me.” You managed to do it, and, in accomplishing that, guaranteed that I will always remember you… just for all the wrong reasons.










